SEARCH
![]() |
Jeff CrosbyOut in the grassroots, workers are mighty angry at the thought their health care benefits could be taxed in a health care reform plan. |
Confessions of a Boston (Union) Sports Fan…or, in Search of an Underdog |
The Orioles fan in the next seat turned to me and said, “Good, we’re only down two runs.” I was sitting in Camden Yards, the baseball stadium in Baltimore. I thought he was joking. It was the top of the first inning, and he was glad that his team was only down two runs to the visiting Boston Red Sox. But there was no smile on his face, just visible relief. Down two after half an inning, and he was all but celebrating!
This was a moment to consider just how long I, as a union guy who has supported underdogs all my life, could continue rooting for big-market, big-spending teams that have become the new Evil Empire.
I rooted for the meatpackers in the Midwest and the janitors taking on the industrial cleaning giants. I tasted tear gas in Seattle, Quebec and Miami, fighting mega-corporate neo-liberal globalization. My local union members are fighting to keep the Saugus town library open at a time when public budgets are disappearing and “the public good” sounds quaint. We fight to keep General Electric Co. (GE) hiring when the public thinks products just appear out of the sky or are all made in China. David-against-Goliath political trends at every turn.
I’ve always been a fan with my heart, not my head. Before I moved to Massachusetts in the late 1970s, I used to follow the Milwaukee Brewers, with lovable players like “Stormin’ ” Gorman Thomas. Thomas famously told the press:
I try to keep the fans entertained. I can usually hit a home run, or maybe run into a wall, or something.
I read Dave Zirin’s edgeofsports.com religiously. I have a righteous union rap for everything I do.
I can’t gamble more than a dollar on a football pool. Otherwise I’ll lose next month’s mortgage betting on whichever team’s city lost the most industrial jobs since NAFTA [the North American Free Trade Agreement].
The old guy running the elevator at Camden Yards, who fondly remembered Brooks and Frank Robinson, told me it was 8–1 Red Sox fans that night. The hotels were overrun with people like me, down for a vacation to see the Sox. (You have to know Dan Duquette to get into Boston’s Fenway Park these days.) A hot selling T-shirt proclaimed the beautiful Camden Yards to be “Fenway South.” The most popular shirt for the beleaguered Orioles fan was Cal Ripken—and he has been retired long enough to be in the Hall of Fame.
At one point thousands of Sox fans started chanting, “Yankees Suck.” A weirded-out Orioles fan turned to his friend in wonderment and pointed out:
Will someone tell those guys that the Yankees aren’t even here?
And what about the embarrassing Patriots, New England’s pro football entry. I collected autographs from “Babe” Parilli and Gino Cappelletti when you could stand on the sidelines of the pre-season practice fields and watch for nothing, as long as you didn’t get in the way. Today the Kraft family is building some kind of Patriot theme park next to the brand-new zillion dollar stadium that will be a year-long Patriot shrine.
The Pats average 35 points a game after importing more stars. They have players suspended for failing drug tests and a coach fined for filming their opponent’s signals. They are favored to win the Super Bowl and are more popular by the day. How excited can you get about a team that is favored to win every game and then proceeds to do just that—methodically? I actually fell asleep on the couch when they were clobbering Cincinnati on Monday Night Football.
I saw Bill Russell and Cousy play in the old Boston Garden, and surfed the ups and downs that followed. I hung in there for the past 10 seasons, rooting for the unknown young players who filed through the revolving door to throw the ball to Paul Pierce at the end of every game. Now the Celtics have Kevin Garnett and Ray Allen to complement Pierce. Last year they didn’t make the playoffs. This year anything less than the Finals will be a disappointment.
Boston College, the only college team in town that plays Division 1 football, is undefeated and fourth ranked in the nation, higher than when quarterback Doug Flutie won the Heisman Trophy there in 1984.
I never followed the hockey Bruins much. I moved to Pakistan when my Dad was in the service and I was in elementary school . Not a lot of ice in the North West Frontier Province around Peshawar. Loyalties start young, and I have never been a big fan of the recent local soccer entry, the Revolution, although I played when I returned home from Pakistan. So I am stuck with all these winners.
There is always some justification for supporting the Empire (ask any American). Like the players who imagine that they “get no respect” to fire themselves up, I focus on individual stories to justify supporting league bullies. The Sox have baseball’s knuckle-balling Everyman, Tim Wakefield, who is 40 years old and pitches slower than I do—I could run and catch my own ball, and I can’t run much. Plus Wakefield saved neighbors from a housefire and was the union rep for the team for a while.
Yeah, Flutie scabbed on the players’ strike. But Patriots quarterback Tom Brady “spreads the wealth” right, by using all his receivers. Isn’t that what we do in unions? He must be one of us, under the glitter. New Celtics star Kevin Garnet slipped his security in Rome so he could drop some cash into the hands of a street beggar.
How good is that?
Yeah, the Sox were the last team in the majors to finally sign black players. But Sox Dominican slugger “Big Papi” Ortiz wore Jackie Robinson’s number this year to commemorate his breakthrough against segregation, saying, “He did it for all of us.” And the Celtics were the first in the NBA to sign black athletes, and as Boston Globe reporter Derrick Jackson pointed out, they hired several black coaches when that was a rarity. The Bruins signed the first black player in the NHL.
There is always a balm for my relentless union underdog conscience.
But if you are looking for the real local feel-good story, there is Everett High School football. The gritty blue-collar town of 33,000 boasts the only New England high school football team ranked nationally in years. Coach John DiBiaso runs a class program, leading a United Nations of tough kids who start gripping a football in the crib and use football to further their education. While several Everett kids have played in the NFL, even second string players have received college scholarships. The Everett 12-year-old Pop Warner team beat Texas in last year’s national tournament in Florida by thirty points. “Friday Night Lights” got nothing on us.
The other ranked high school teams are mostly prep or Catholic schools that recruit from a much wider area. And Everett used to have a GE plant, built for them by the government during WWII. They made parts for my Dad’s B-17 Flying Fortress bomber when he was navigator in the Army Air Corps. The plant is closed, the work consolidated into Lynn, so the school also warms my foolish rust-belt heart. Go Everett, beat yuppies.
A few weeks after my trip to Camden Yards, I was back on the couch watching the Sox. Down the Yankees, 4–3. Two out in the ninth, Big Papi facing Mariano Rivera. Hanging on every pitch. Big Papi popped out.
A few weeks after that, I parked myself on a couch at my son’s place in Vermont. He and my wife and I watched the Patriots win, then the Red Sox win, then the Yankees lose. An eight-hour trifecta. (And yet next week at the Union Hall I’ll be adding my voice to the “busier than thou” chorus, wondering where the time went.)
I could get used to this. I’ll work on the political rationale for my devotion later.
Note: Thanks for Tony Dunn, North Shore Labor Council United Way Labor Liaison, and Fred Merchant, Local 201 Executive Board member, and Everett fan-atic, for fact checking the work of this casual fan.
8 Comments
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.













One trhing you failed to mention: Bill Belickick’s father was a union organizer in Ohio.
One thing you failed to mention: Bill Belickick’s grandfather was a union organizer in Ohio.
Never knew that. Anybody know what union Belichick’s grandfather organized for?
I posted, what I felt was a stimulating challenge, on this blog a few days ago. I posted under COMMENTS about the KENTUCKY BUS TOUR. Thisis a new spot, with a face.
My post was never included n the comments. I will try again and make it brief. The Union needs to support a candidate that promises to AMEND or RESEND the North American Free Trade Agreement.
This legislation, with has taken over one million of our jobs to third world countries, has to be changed to level the playing field.
It will not be easily done, THE FORTUNE 500, are heavily entrenched with the Congress so we know who owns that ball and who calls the rules.
Surely the AFL CIO has a staff attorney, that can look at the document, see where it is lopsided and then come to the Union with recommendations on how to level the playing field. This very ammendment could be given to the candidates for the Congress in advance with a heads up they agree NAFTA is a problem.
The entire MIDDLE CLASS has been severely impacted by this trade agreement. Not only does it allow Fortune 500 to manufacture in third world countries, ie CHINA , MEXICO, INDIA,
when the product is imported, to the USA, the taxes and the tariff’s are reduced. How much I don’t know, but enough so that it makes a difference.
Besides THE IRAQ OCCUPATION this, IMO, is the SINGLE MOST IMPORTANT ISSUE FACING THE WORKING CLASS.
So, AFL CIO what are we, (I will help) going to do about it?
my email adrs is jstivers@fewpb.net
I hate to public list my email, but if you want some help and an activist that knows something about the issue , write me.
I expect to get the hate letters also. But, don’t sit on your duff.
This issue should have been a HEAVY, HEAVY PUSH BACK when it was being considered under Bill Clinton. It was later we find out the ASIANS are big contributors to Bill, Hilary and whomever else they can buy.
Mr. Crosby, If you are the individual that allowed my post-THANK YOU.
Now lets see if an “pissed off” activist want to pick up this banner and wave, then when successful plant in the ground in Washington to sow the Congress, UNIONS ARE TOGETHER and you better not screw us and our families again.
Jim Anderson Stivers
(Retired Sr. Project Manger, Cabinet for Economic Development,
Commonwealth of Kentucky)
I have seen both sides of this recruiting issue and, like all states, manufacturing jobs are dissaprearing, WHY?
Mr. Crosby, If you are the individual that allowed my post-
THANK YOU.
Fabulous blog! Tons of union guys and gals I know are sports fanatics and the more we write/analyze about sports the more we can connect to the vast majority of union members who are almost completely inactive.
I totally understand your mixed feelings concerning the super-successful Patriots and Red Sox lately. Since the mid-nineties I’ve been railing about the evil-empire Yankees and their buying cham
pionships. The Red Sox are now the junior evil-empire in terms of spending (though still many tens of millions less than the Yankees) compared to the rest of MLB. Grossly outspending nearly all the competition sucks and is not good for MLB.
The Patriots are much different since they can’t buy a Super Bowl. Teamwork, defense, superior coaching and organization, commitment to eliminating mental and physical mistakes, etc are reasons for their success.
Growing up as a kid in New Bedford in the 60’s the Red Sox were the ultimate underdogs (’cept for the Cubs). But at the end of every season without the championship, we still had the Celtics who would mop up the rest of the NBA for the whole decade. We could always count on listening to the radio and the fabulous Celtic defense clamping down their opponent in the fourth quarter for the win. Bill Russell is the greatest individual winner in team sports in U.S. history. Eleven championships in thirteen NBA seasons, two NCAA championships and an Olympic gold medal in 1956. Michael Jordan doesn’t measure up.
Bill Russell also wrote the best sports book ever in my humble opinion. “Second Wind” is a great read and touches on so much more than sports (imperialism, racism, unreal personal narratives, etc). Only drawback is his chapter on women - pretty sexist.
We need more Dave Zirins writing on sports from progressive viewpoint. Finally, Dan Duquete gone from Boston Red Sox since ‘02. Theo Epstein is GM. Keep writing about the sports world!
Pete Arsenault
Still, about the Pats: When even the corporate GE types that I meet with from time to time speak admiring of them as a “Business Model”, and I hear the owners family talk about not treating the organization as a sports team as much as a Business Model, it starts to make my hair stand up on end. And I can see both sides of the “piling on” debate–it is more sportsmanlike to kick a field goal when you’re up 42-7, which is almost automatic, or to go for it on 4th and 3, which at least gives the opponent a chance to stop you?
But any questioning of the team these days sets off talk about the “whining of the losers”. I read 4 different newspaper articles or letters this week talking about how any criticism of the Patriots running up the score means we “no longer seek excellence” in this country, etc, etc. Starts to sound like some neo-liberal ode to the efficiency of the free market. That’s why I can’t stand to listen to what one pundit here called “the fellowship of the miserable” on sports talk radio.
Best thing that could happen is if they lose a game along the way and then go to the Super Bowl and win it. It would make for a lot more interesting season than the limited pleasure of watching the weekly “clinic” against the designated junior varsity squad. Wasn’t the Eagles game the best one since Indianapolis? I even stayed awake to the end.